Jump to content
Forums Gone... but not forgotten!

Tired of these Ads? Register Today!

  • Welcome to Forever Pontiac

    Welcome to Forever Pontiac, full of great ideas for Pontiac performance, maintenance, or for peer-to-peer assistance from Professional and DIY mechanics. Also, compete in our Pontiac monthly competitions. Please register if you'd like to take part.

Sign in to follow this  
FeedBot

Car and Driver: The Tesla Roadster Was a Disaster, Admits Elon Musk

Recommended Posts

2010 Tesla Roadster Sport
-Remember back in 2008, when Jeremy Clarkson reviewed the then-new Tesla Roadster and portrayed it as a barely running science experiment that couldn’t survive a full day at the Top Gear track? At the time, Tesla bristled at the BBC’s insinuations. But in a somewhat rambling keynote during a Tesla shareholder’s meeting yesterday, CEO Elon Musk basically admitted that the Roadster project was a complete debacle.

-

Fortune‘s Katie Fehrenbacher took detailed notes of Musk’s lengthy retelling of the Tesla origin story, including his revelations of previously unpublicized problems that arose during the automaker’s first foray into building an electric car.

-

In the early days, it sounds like Musk didn’t even give his fledgling company, now 13 years old, a fighting chance at survival. On stage at the annual shareholders’ meeting in Mountain View, California, Musk revealed that he thought the company only had a 10-percent chance of surviving when he first co-founded it with engineer (now chief technical officer) JB Straubel. Saying that in the early days, they had “no idea what we are doing,” and characterizing their original efforts as “completely clueless,” Musk admitted that he wanted to invest 99 percent of the company’s Series A funding, to avoid having investors and friends lose money on the endeavor.

-

Musk says that the company was founded in 2003 based on assumptions which “turned out to be staggeringly dumb.” Mostly, he was referring to the original business plan for the Roadster, when Tesla’s heads figured they could turn a profit on the Roadster by licensing drivetrain technology from the startup AC Propulsion and packing it into chassis provided by Lotus.

-

As Fehrenbacher writes in Fortune, that daydream proved completely impossible:

-
-

That technology from AC Propulsion could not be reproduced and commercialized, said Musk and Straubel. That was partly because the information system that ran the motor was analog, instead of digital, so engineers had to rewrite all of the code involved. Another reason was because the AC Propulsion battery pack was air-cooled, which didn’t provide enough cooling for batteries that get hot when they discharge to power an electric car. Tesla later converted the Roadster’s battery pack to be liquid-cooled instead.

-
-

In the end, Musk said, the final design of the Roadster only contained around six or seven percent of the technology licensed from AC Propulsion and Lotus. The Lotus Elise platform had to be stretched to accommodate the batteries; Lotus’s U.S. crash-test results couldn’t be applied to the modified design, necessitating expensive crash testing; Straubel revealed that the entire suspension and braking systems had to be redesigned for the Tesla.

-

Musk compared the ordeal to building a house by remodeling an existing structure until only one basement wall was left.

-

Even when all that unexpected re-engineering was completed, the Roadster was still a basket case. Musk said that when he took Google co-founders Larry Page and Sergei Brin for a ride in an early Roadster, the car wouldn’t do more than 10 mph. “I was like, ‘I swear guys it goes way faster than this,'” said Musk. Page and Brin “were kind enough to put a little money in the company despite the world’s worst demo,” he said.

-

The problems continued. At the Roadster launch party in 2006, a few examples were on hand to give rides to potential customers. By the end of the night, “the cars were destroyed,” Straubel said. Musk admitted that the early Roadster “was completely unsafe,” it “broke down all the time,” and it “didn’t really work.”

-

Somehow, the company survived. The Roadster production process was completely overhauled in 2008 and 2009, with major changes to component suppliers and internal technology. Tesla also brought its battery production in-house at that time. It was late 2009 before Tesla stopped losing money on every Roadster it sold.

-

Musk said he wanted to talk about Tesla’s early stumbles to let future entrepreneurs know that they can make mistakes and enter unfamiliar industries and still have a chance at success. But as we know, the young electric carmaker isn’t out of the woods just yet.

-

Musk’s ambitions for increased Tesla production are highly dubious. He’s already said that the Model 3, the long-promised $35,000 Tesla meant to bring practical electric cars to the masses, will likely be delayed. The recently introduced Model X SUV has had so many quality-control problems, Musk has been living out of a sleeping bag at the end of the assembly line to monitor production.

-
--
-

The CEO’s apology tour didn’t just extend to the Roadster: During the shareholder’s meeting, Musk also pointed out that the biggest problem with the Model X—those ridiculous “falconwing” rear doors—hasn’t even been fixed yet. “We’re almost there in making the doors useful,” he said, promising that they’ll work better than regular doors within the next month or so

-

This story originally appeared on Road & Track.

-XKxfxg9-gcc

Read Full Article

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tired of these Ads? Register Today!

Still has to get those charge times down and find a way to keep the batteries from taking a dump in the cold of winter. My biggest peeve isn't just the time charging ... it's trying to get space at public chargers.  It's like waiting to fill at the pump while the cu t at the pump is browsing brands of potato chips and trying to decide (with his 3 remaining brain cells) what soda would go best with it.

Edited by Professur

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

Tired of these Ads? Purchase Enhanced Membership today to remove them!
×

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.